Yates published his October Dynasty Trade Value Chart, and unsurprisingly, we have valued a few players quite differently. I took a look at some of these players, here’s my thoughts. As usual, I appreciate any feedback - namecalling is accepted.
Pos |
Name |
Yates |
Zak |
Diff |
Who’s Right |
QB |
Justin Fields |
45 |
38 |
7 |
Yates |
QB |
Aaron Rodgers |
36 |
45 |
-9 |
Yates |
QB |
Jameis Winston |
22 |
26 |
-4 |
Zak |
QB |
Ben Roethlisberger |
14 |
10 |
4 |
Zak |
QB |
Andy Dalton |
12 |
4 |
8 |
Zak |
Justin Fields - I agree with Yates, he needs to be bumped up more. But then we also gotta move Andy Dalton down.
Aaron Rodgers - I agree with Yates, he needs to be downgraded due to the fact we may see his final season (as discussed above).
Jameis Winston - I stand by my TV. Winston looks solid. The lack of offensive weapons is not his fault. If he still doesn’t produce when Thomas and Smith are back on the field, then I’m ready to downgrade him. The involvement of Hill isn’t enough of a reason for me. That won’t last, and Jameis is still young.
Ben Roethlisberger - I stand by my verdict. Big Ben looks like a shadow of his former self, his o-line is horrible, and he’s definitely in his final season, which I even expect to end prematurely. Big Ben holds close to no dynasty value anymore, even my TV may be too high.
Pos |
Name |
Yates |
Zak |
Diff |
Who’s Right |
RB |
Dalvin Cook |
80 |
72 |
8 |
Zak |
RB |
Najee Harris |
61 |
68 |
-7 |
Zak |
RB |
Ezekiel Elliott |
61 |
50 |
11 |
Zak |
RB |
James Robinson |
42 |
26 |
16 |
Yates |
RB |
Josh Jacobs |
32 |
36 |
-4 |
Zak |
RB |
Miles Sanders |
26 |
38 |
-12 |
Yates |
RB |
Kenyan Drake |
19 |
12 |
7 |
Zak |
RB |
Sony Michel |
17 |
10 |
7 |
Zak |
RB |
Cordarrelle Patterson |
2 |
7 |
-5 |
Split |
Dalvin Cook - staying with my TV. He’s getting older, he’s injured. I would have accepted to leave his TV unchanged for the moment, but even adding 4 ticks? Sorry, no.
Najee Harris - staying with my TV. He’s an RB1 right out out of the gate. There is no reason to believe that will change. Even my number may be too low.
Ezekiel Elliott - staying with my TV. Okay, maybe I’m a tad too low. But Pollard is cutting deeply into his production. We’re close to an RBBC there. And Zeke isn’t getting any younger.
James Robinson - I agree with Yates, I had him too low. His next-year outlook is still somewhat cloudy, but we gotta see if, when and how Etienne is able to enter the NFL stage.
Josh Jacobs - staying with my TV. He has shown that the Raiders backfield is still his. That’s why I also stick with my lower ranking for Kenyan Drake. He didn’t pick up steam even with Jacobs out. He plays a role in the offense, but it’s a limited one.
Miles Sanders - I agree with Yates. His starting job is in real danger, he’s getting outperformed by Kenny Gainwell.
Sony Michel - staying with my TV. He’s a handcuff with an expiry date. No reason to bump up his TV.
Cordarrelle Patterson - split. As discussed above, I think he has very limited trade value, despite his hot streak. I’m still okay with my 7, but can also easily accept Yates’ 2.
Pos |
Name |
Yates |
Zak |
Diff |
Who’s Right |
WR |
Cooper Kupp |
58 |
46 |
12 |
Yates |
WR |
DeAndre Hopkins |
54 |
66 |
-12 |
Zak |
WR |
Chase Claypool |
44 |
34 |
10 |
Zak |
WR |
Michael Pittman |
40 |
30 |
10 |
Split |
WR |
Diontae Johnson |
38 |
48 |
-10 |
Zak |
WR |
Mike Williams |
32 |
24 |
8 |
Yates |
WR |
Brandon Aiyuk |
30 |
40 |
-10 |
Yates |
WR |
Henry Ruggs |
29 |
17 |
12 |
Split |
WR |
Laviska Shenault |
22 |
34 |
-12 |
Split |
WR |
KJ Hamler |
9 |
0 |
9 |
Zak |
WR |
Van Jefferson |
6 |
14 |
-8 |
Yates |
Cooper Kupp - I agree with Yates, had him too low.
DeAndre Hopkins - staying with my TV. The Cards are looking great, and there will be better games ahead for D-Hop. No reason yet to decrease his TV by that much.
Chase Claypool - staying with my TV. Is anybody seeing something I don’t? His production is underwhelming, and we don’t know who will throw him the ball next year (or even later this season)… I am fine with leaving his TV unchanged, but bump him by 10 points? Why?
Diontae Johnson - also staying with my TV. I would accept leaving his TV unchanged as well, due to the uncertain future of the franchise. But he’s the #1 target, so why drop his value?
Michael Pittman - split decision. I’m okay with bumping him up a little more, Another 10 points seem a bit much, though.
Mike Williams - I agree with Yates, I had him too low.
Brandon Aiyuk - Yates has him right. I didn’t dare dropping his value even further than I did, but I should have.
Henry Ruggs - split decision. I moved him down by 1 point, Yates moved him up by 11. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
Laviska Shenault - split decision. I stand by the decision to move him up, but I probably went too far. I only looked at the Chark injury, but not at the poor QB play (and poor state of the entire franchise).
KJ Hamler - staying with my TV. Which is zero. Hamler was a “maybe” going into this season. He has much better receivers ahead of him, and has shown nothing so far that would indicate he could leapfrog them. And now he tore his ACL, which ended his season. And his dynasty stock is rising? I also noted he made a big jump in the dynasty ECR. Why??
Van Jefferson - I agree with Yates. Bumped him a little too far. The trend looks good, but the sample size is still too small.
Pos |
Name |
Yates |
Zak |
Diff |
Who’s Right |
TE |
Kyle Pitts |
49 |
37 |
12 |
Split |
TE |
George Kittle |
40 |
46 |
-6 |
Yates |
TE |
Jonnu Smith |
20 |
26 |
-6 |
Yates |
TE |
Dalton Schultz |
16 |
10 |
6 |
Yates |
TE |
Irv Smith |
15 |
6 |
9 |
Zak |
TE |
Adam Trautman |
14 |
8 |
6 |
Zak |
Kyle Pitts - Split decision. Why did I move him down by 3 points? I honestly can’t say. Moving him up by 9 points appears a bit too much as well, though. Did he show anything in September that we did not anticipate in August already?
George Kittle - I agree with Yates, he needs to be moved down further than I did.
Jonnu Smith - I agree with Yates. I have to. I listened to him when acquiring Jonnu almost everywhere. Guess I have to listen to him when reducing Jonnu’s value now as well. The TE situation in New England istn’t pretty.
Dalton Schultz - I agree with Yates. I didn’t dare to move Schultz up any further, but there is no reason not to.
Irv Smith - I stay with my TV. Like KJ Hamler, Smith is another mystery case of “stock increased after a season ending injury”. Honestly, I don’t get it!
Adam Trautman - I stay with my TV. Trautman’s previous value was based on the expectation that he’d get a significant share of a notable Saints passing volume. Neither of both has happened.