Keeper Q- Riley (5th rd pick) OR Mclain (16th rd pick)

Austin Riley for a 5th round pick OR Matt Mclain for a 16th round pick?

Without knowing the specifics of your league… Riley is a top 20 overall player. Fifth round is good value. McLain can be drafted between picks 40-100 reasonably. In a 10-12 league team that’s between rounds 4-10. I’d keep Riley and target McLain.