Next year, I will try increasing the “made FG’s” scoring to see if I can get them fully in line with the RB’s and WR’s. With a 32 point difference on the high end, that is easily a one point adjustment to a scoring category.
Top Ks score 12+ PPG, average ones around 9, bad ones 6-7. And there’s one K almost every week scoring around 20 FFP.
I had toyed with some settings to widen the gap, but that led to some pretty random results. As kicker play tends to be random enough as it is (I’m no longer opposed to do away with the K and DST position), I did not find that desirable.
The team owners in that league seems to be pretty happy with the current settings.
Who cares what the top 25 Ks do when only 10 or 12 of them are rostered?
Who cares if they score 10 points a week or 100 points a week, you can only compare them to other kickers anway, not the other positions (unless of course you can start a K in a QB or RB slot in your league).
Just make it 0.1 pts x the length of the FG, and be done with it.