The top four WRs as of now are pretty much equal depending on you taste. They are all special.
2023 Dynasty Rookie Rankings: Wide Receivers
1) Jordan Addison, USC
Some will find it blasphemous not to have Jaxon Smith-Njigba as my No. 1, and before you lose it, just look one spot down. Similar to the 2023 RBs, the receivers in this incoming rookie class are ridiculously talented, and in all reality, we have a Tier 1 of four guys, so it’s a bit of picking your poison.
Unfortunately, Addison’s stats likely won’t stand up to others in this class. He suffered a leg injury against Utah and was seen on crutches but luckily avoided a major injury. If it was me, Addison could take the Ja’Marr Chase approach and hang up the cleats and focus on the NFL.
Addison plucks the ball out of the sky and explodes to the high point. He’s a twitchy runner who also is a serious threat after the catch. I can’t help be see a lot of Justin Jefferson in his game, and we know where Jefferson sits in dynasty rankings.
2) Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Ohio State
If the NFL rules were different on draft eligibility, Smith-Njigba would be in the NFL right now. As a sophomore, he was everything and more for an otherwordly talented OSU offense.
Recording 95 receptions, Smith-Njigba set a Big Ten single-season record with 1,606 receiving yards. With Garrett Wilson and Chris Olave sitting out the postseason as they focused on the NFL draft, Smith-Njigba set a Rose Bowl record in 2021 with 347 receiving yards on 15 receptions and was named MVP.
MORE: What Is a Dynasty Rookie Draft?
His hands and route running are phenomenal. He’s an elite separator, has sensational body control, and is as smart as it gets with how he operates over the middle of the field against zone coverage. The only thing missing from his skill set is top-end speed.
It also appears that Smith-Njigba is set to return at some point in 2023 but when is up in the air. It looked like it would happen against Penn State, but he was inactive. I don’t care if he plays or not, honestly. We’ve seen more than enough out of him already to know he is NFL-ready. At this point, all I care about is the landing spot.
3) Quentin Johnston, TCU
Everybody has a type of people they go for in life. I know I do, but I’ll keep this to football and not my dating history.
When it comes to wideouts, I’ve got a thing for the big dudes. The ones with the size you can’t teach that can just alpha someone at the catch point. That’s Quentin Johnston. Of the Tier 1 guys, he’s the only one who has truly broken out in 2022 and improved his draft stock compared to Addison, JSN, and Kayshon Boutte.
At 6’4″ and 210+ pounds, Johnston’s got a size advantage over 99% of corners and uses every inch of his frame to high-point with the best of them. But for a guy his size, Johnston has a surprising level of burst and acceleration. He’s also surprisingly agile out of inward routes like slants when he sells the outside move.
Of the top-ranked receivers of this class, Johnston might be having the most impressive season so far. After a slow start, Johnston put up 206 yards with a TD on 14 receptions vs. Kansas, and in Week 7, he had 180 and another score vs. Oklahoma State. Through eight games, Johnston sits 10th amongst 2023 WRs with a 2.40 YPTPA (yards per team passing attempt).
He’s checking all of the boxes. I’m betting on Johnston’s upside as a top-four WR at minimum in 2023 dynasty rookie rankings. If anything, I can see some preferring Johnston as the No. 2 wideout of this class or even No. 1 overall even if that’s not where I’m at currently.
4) Kayshon Boutte, LSU
Back in 2020, Kayshon Boutte was my top receiver in this class, and not much has changed. The former SEC Freshman All-American is an explosive receiver that can align at a multitude of positions, whether it’s on the perimeter, as an X, or in the slot. Boutte even broke the SEC record for yards in a single game back in 2020 with a whopping 308.
Once he has the ball in his hands, Boutte has enough strength to break a few arm tackles, and then his speed kicks in. He’s as smooth as it gets when at full stride and can stack darn near any corner you line up against him. When Boutte comes out of breaks, there is an explosion in every step, which is how he creates separation.
The numbers won’t wow you. Boutte had 1,244 yards in his first two seasons and has 288 and a TD on 27 receptions this year. But we must remember there has been a coaching change over this time and an inability to replace the hole left by Joe Burrow. Boutte led the NCAA in touchdowns through six games last year before suffering a season-ending injury.
His best game so far in 2022 came against Florida with 115 yards on nine receptions, but he has been sub-45 yards in the other six of seven games, and barely snuck out with a 51-yard outing in the team’s incredible victory over Alabama. Boutte is one of those WRs who will instantly out anyone that is a “box-score evaluator” that uses those to tell them who is good or not.
Boutte is great at high-pointing but could work on consistency in contested catches (27.8% catch rate) and his hands (12.5% drop rate). He hasn’t boosted his stock in 2022 thus far compared to others, but the upside is great enough to overlook some of the numbers, as stats/spreadsheets don’t win routes or get you open in the NFL.
He fits the mold of the modern NFL, where a No. 1 target is more in the slot rather than a traditional “X” that can take a five-yard slant and turn it into a 50+ yard gain. This is a process over stats ranking.